Journal Entry

Wednesday, December 29, 2004

Tsunami Relief: Charity Efficiency and Transparency Ratings

My contribution to the blogosphere's response to the tsunami...

Here's Google's tsunami relief page, here's the Tsunami Blog and Wiki, and here is a table with ratings by watchdog organizations on the efficiency of the relief organizations most prominently mentioned, plus news:

(Since Charity Navigator's site seems to be having trouble with heavy load, I am adding links to the Google cache of their ratings, following the stars.)


Relief organization Charity Navigator's rating (and Google cache thereof) AIP's rating Fulfills BBB's transparency criteria? Notes News
Association for India's Development ****     (cached) not rated not rated Seems to be big in India, oft mentioned on tsunami blog News
Medecins Sans Frontieres
(Doctors w/o Borders)
***     (cached) A Yes Spends a lot on fundraising, but has a reputation for boldness -- going where many others don't (e.g. Myanmar?) News
Oxfam ***     (cached) A- No Spends a lot on fundraising. BBB objects to dodgy credit card promotion. News
UNICEF not rated not rated not rated An article in Lancet(free registration required) criticizes the present director's focus on childrens' legal rights at the expense of basic survival aid. Anyone have any data on UNICEF's own efficiency, as opposed to national charities funneling money to it? News
American Red Cross(via Amazon) ****     (cached) A+ Yes Big but apparently efficient; came under fire for usage of 9/11 funds and related issues; the BBB report has lots of details News
World Vision ****     (cached) B+ Yes Christian charity with child and family sponsorships, added by request; US site having trouble? News
Mercy Corps ****     (cached) B+ Yes added by request News
American Friends Service Committee not rated A- Yes Quaker charity; added by request News
Asha for Education ****     (cached) not rated not rated Extremely efficient (volunteer staff, 98% to programs); usually focuses on education and long-term socioeconomic change, but responding to the disaster; added by request News
Blog
American Jewish World Service ****     (cached) A not rated Jewish international development charity; added by request News
Salvation Army not rated not rated Yes Christian relief organization, added by request. Huge(13.5K employees), reputed to be very efficient (86% of funds to projects, volunteerism), low-key proselytizing, accused of discrimination against gays News
Unitarian Universalist Service Committee **     (cached) not rated Yes Unitarian relief organization, added by request. News
Christian Children's Fund ***     (cached) A Yes Historically Christian, but apparently non-proselytizing international relief and development organization, added by request News
Americares ****     (cached) A Yes Extremely efficient (99% to programs) nonprofit specialized in international disasters, added by request News
Islamic Relief Worldwide ****     (cached) not rated not rated Islamic relief organization, has relief operations running (from before the disaster) in Sri Lanka and in Indonesia, added by request News
Sarvodaya not rated not rated not rated Local Sri Lankan charity, recommended by Sir Arthur C. Clarke: "a 45 year track record in reaching out and helping the poorest of the poor...has mounted a well organised, countrywide relief effort". News
Blog
Catholic Relief Services not rated A- Yes Catholic relief organization, added by request News

These ratings do not necessarily tell the whole story. The efficiency ratings rely on the distinction between "administrative", "promotional", and "administrative" expenses: what constitutes "program" expenses may vary greatly from charity to charity. For instance, the United States Fund for UNICEF gets four stars because 88.5% percent of its revenues go to "programs". But "programs" in this case means "giving the money to UNICEF" (as well it should, since that's its mandate). The 3.4% of administrative expenses listed does not include UNICEF's own administrative expenses. (However, UNICEF's FAQ says "you can choose to earmark your contribution for the tsunami relief effort...As each of UNICEF’s Country Offices have their own annual budget to cover their overhead costs, your donation can go solely to the relief effort").

It pays to poke around. Look in the comments of this post for people's discussion of pros and cons of different charities, in addition to my own decisions.

Network for Good, also mentioned on the Google page, does not itself accept donations for tsunami relief, but rather provides further links to several different charities.

eBay's Tsunami Disaster Relief Page allows you to sell things on eBay and automatically donate 10-100% of the proceeds to one of eight charities.

If you are specifically interested in any others, let me know and I'll add them. I'm also interested in other feedback and reports on the charities, particularly if you have links (such as to news articles) that can document any problems that may be relevant.

American Institute of Philanthropy's criteria. Here is their page on the most effective ways to help victims of the tsunami (e.g. it's better to donate money than goods, beware of fly-by-night charities).

Charity Navigator's criteria ( or via the Google cache).

The Tsunami blog also mentions various other funds which are local to India and SE Asia; I don't have any information on their efficiency or transparency.

Give wisely, generously, and soon.


Update: Now that many billions of dollars have been earmarked for tsunami relief and reconstruction, by governments, corporations, and private individuals, you may want to consider donating to these charities' general funds, rather than earmarking your donation for the tsunami. Though the tsunami is the worst natural disaster of recent times, killing more than 150,000 people, it is dwarfed by things like AIDS (which has killed 19 million people and is destroying much of sub-Saharan Africa) and the war in the Congo (which has killed 3.8 million people, mainly from disease and starvation, since 1998). Posted by benrosen at December 29, 2004 08:08 AM | Up to blog

Comments

I suggest World Vision? They are a Christian charity with child and family sponsorships, with a project-vs-admin ratio of $0.86 per dollar (to projects) (worldvision.org)...

Posted by: Mike at December 29, 2004 09:49 AM

I'd like to see data on how these charities handled 9/11 donations. I'm not giving a dime to a certain organization that squandered our goodwill.

Posted by: JS at December 29, 2004 10:12 AM

Here's the rating for UNICEF: http://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm/bay/search.summary/orgid/4617.htm

It's usually listed under United States Fund for UNICEF. It got **** from Charity Navigator.

Posted by: Joe at December 29, 2004 10:17 AM

Sorry to post again:

From BBB: Yes for UNICEF

http://give.org/reports/care_dyn.asp?438

I don't see it on AIP.

Posted by: Joe at December 29, 2004 10:23 AM

I'd really like to see efficiency information included along with the other criteria. Perhaps also a 'tick-the-box' situation as to whether donations go towards proselytising too.

Posted by: Jackson at December 29, 2004 10:25 AM

JS: the BBB report on the Red Cross discusses in detail their handling of the 9/11 money. They are still sitting on some of it, but there may be good reasons for that. I haven't run across other discussions of that aspect, but I'm sure there are some out there.

Joe: Actually I looked at that, but the problem is that the United States Fund for UNICEF seems to be a "funnel" charity. They are efficient in terms of their major "project", which is grants to UNICEF. That doesn't, however, tell you what UNICEF does with the money, in terms of real projects vs. administrative/bureaucratic overhead, etc.

Jackson, that would be interesting; but I don't know where to get that information, and it's also hard to define "proselytizing". I'm a big fan of the Grameen Foundation, which is a secular charity and doesn't proselytize in a religious sense -- but they do promote particular social practices, even to the extent of, for instance, asking credit recipients to pledge not to engage in dowry marriage! Is that proselytizing?

So your best bet with regards to that issue is to go to the charity's website and poke around to see if their philosophy fits yours, and what they consider "programs".

Posted by: Benjamin Rosenbaum at December 29, 2004 10:47 AM

Consider adding:
Mercy Corps (AIP B+; BBB yes: Charity Navigator ****)
American Friends Service Committee (AIP A-; BBB yes; Charity Navigator not listed)

The Charity Navigator site seems slow to load; may be taking a lot of hits today.

Posted by: Maines at December 29, 2004 11:05 AM

Hi,
People might want to consider giving to the following:

The International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societits www.ifrc.org -- the world's largest humanitarian organization.

Posted by: Nancy at December 29, 2004 11:26 AM

Added World Vision, Mercy Corps, AFSC. The watchdogs I'm familiar with seem to have information on the American Red Cross rather than IFRC. However, now I'm wondering if ARC and IFRC have the same funnel/destination relationship as United States Fund for UNICEF and UNICEF, which might artificially inflate ARC's efficiency (i.e., some layers of bureaucracy are "hidden" by the transfer between ARC and IFRC). Anyone know anything about this?

Posted by: Benjamin Rosenbaum at December 29, 2004 12:15 PM

Isn't the Red Cross and United Way constantly coming into little scandals because of how little of each dollar makes it to the victim in need? After 9/11 there was an investigation as to how the Red Cross squandered most the donations for the victims' fund.

How about trying to find out and publish how much of every dollar donated actually goes to the people in need (especially the children)?

Posted by: -lc- at December 29, 2004 12:26 PM

Charity Navigator on CARE (***). Not bad, but had I known about Charity Navigator I may have given to American Red Cross instead. My only criteria were a) doesn't exist to spend money on fundraising (I checked on guidestar) and b) doesn't proselytize for jesus and preferably isn't xian at all.

Posted by: Mike Linksvayer at December 29, 2004 12:29 PM

Association for India's Development (AID) has been active in South India, specially Tamil Nadu since Sunday and has been coordinating relief efforts with local NGOs to reach out in areas where the government, ICRC and UNICEF effort is lacking. AID has already released $75,000 in immediate relief and is working to develop plans for meeting medium term as well as long term needs. For more information and to contribute: http://survivors.aidindia.org/

Thanks.

P.S. At times the web site may be experiencing heavy traffic. Please bear with us.

Posted by: Anup at December 29, 2004 12:47 PM

lc, I added some links relating to the controversy around the American Red Cross's usage of 9/11 funds. There is a breakdown of disbursed money in the BBB report. From a cursory reading, it looks like they were sluggish and bureaucratic about disbursing the money, but most of it has been given out. It also seems like many people thought it was all going to victim's families, when in fact a lot of it went to infrastructural items like call centers. Infrastructure is important too, though.

There was also controversy around the fact that the ICRC knew about the Abu Ghraib abuses and complained in private to the US, rather than going public. "Red Cross workers insist that the policy of talking only to prison authorities about abuses they have witnessed is what opens the prison gates for them."

Big organizations like the Red Cross are to some extent magnets for this kind of complaint (complaining about the financial practices of, say, the National Association of Police Athletic Leagues is not going to make headlines), which is why the hard data collected by the watchdog organizations can be a useful corrective.

There was also a scandal involving ongoing child abuse by local UNHCR and Save the Children employees that may have tangentially involved other NGOs.

Anup, thanks for posting! You were first on the list from the beginning. :-)

Posted by: Benjamin Rosenbaum at December 29, 2004 01:08 PM

A friend in Singapore suggested the Singapore Red Cross. He claims they are very well organized and will likely be a big part of the relief efforts throughout Indonesia.

Posted by: Franky at December 29, 2004 01:39 PM

Thanks, Franky. Does anyone know anything about watchdog organizations outside of the USA?

I also wonder how independent the various Red Crosses are from one another, and whether it might indeed maximize efficiency to donate directly to a local one?

The Singapore Red Cross seems to have online donation. I haven't tried it to see if it takes US credit cards.

Posted by: Benjamin Rosenbaum at December 29, 2004 01:51 PM

Asha for Education is also doing work in the affected areas in India. You can find regular updates at http://ashatsunamirelief.blogspot.com/
To support these relief efforts donations can be made online at http://www.ashanet.org/

Also Please note and correct if possible that AID and Asha for Education have 4 star ratings from Charity Navigator. Both of these organisations are on the ground and working with grass roots project partners to bring relief to the survivors.

http://ashanet.org/index.php?page=charitynav-4star

In Charity Navigator search for "Asha for Education" and "Association for India's DEvelopment"

Posted by: Barnali at December 29, 2004 01:58 PM

Ben,
The only issue with the charity navigator is that it reports charities that receive more than $500,000 in public support with require 4 years of Forms 990 to complete an evaluation.

Ours usually is under $50K (as 90% of our work is pro-bono) and as we are a small organization 0% is spent on admin. - I don't take a salary and cover admin. costs. We also work with partners who employ local labor and utilize construction techniques.

By working with those affected this keeps funds within the community and creates micro-economies for those trying to get out of this disaster. We have found this to be the most cost-effective way of rebuilding.

Back on topic I think Guidestar is more inclusive but there support sucks (online updating has been down for FOUR months and no-one returns calls).

Cheers for bringing this topic up - it is vitally important in relief work.

Cameron

Posted by: Cameron Sinclair at December 29, 2004 02:07 PM

I made a donation through American Jewish World Service which is a wonderful and efficient org. www.ajws.org

Posted by: sarah at December 29, 2004 02:20 PM

One last thought - any massive organization such as the Red Cross already has disaster supplies at hand and in stock, they don't run to the store the moment someone hands them a check. They also have emergency funds at hand for dispursement. Any money going to them is for future restocking, not to help someone tomorrow or next week. IMHO, the smaller and mid-sized organizations are the ones I want give to, they logically should move faster and have less administration overhead (Red Cross spent $100 million out of the 9/11 $500 million on telecommunications, accounting and database management systems???!!!) Apparently they have $2 billion in assets right now: http://google.com/search?q=cache:www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm/bay/search.summary/orgid/3277.htm
compare that to $15 million Unicef assets:
http://google.com/search?q=cache:www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm/bay/search.summary/orgid/4617.htm

Posted by: -lc- at December 29, 2004 02:32 PM

Hi Cameron, that's a good point: the small organizations must really slip through the cracks. Perhaps I can add Guidestar ratings later, if I have time. Your organization looks really cool.

(The other problem with Charity Navigator is that they're generating all their pages dynamically as Java servlets on JRun; I think they're finding out today that that doesn't scale. :-/ But that's what Google is for, I guess...)

Sarah, I added AJWS.

Posted by: Benjamin Rosenbaum at December 29, 2004 02:38 PM

How does The Salvation Army rate?

Posted by: Frank at December 29, 2004 02:48 PM

Its very troubling to see that Network Solutions has somehow fouled up the DNS routing for the Doctors Without Borders website. if you TRY to go to http://www.doctorswithoutborders.org you quickly get routed to some Network Associates Search page that offers other charities to give funds to! Of course, folks get listed on the NetAss Search engine page by paying placement fees, but I'd call it outrageous to see this kind of situation where one charity turns up when you tried to go to another.

Someone needs to help Doctors Without Borders out - and you folks have more combined clout that a casual and humble HTML coder like me ...

Here is the URL I got when I tried to go to the http://www.doctorswithoutborders.org address http://apps5.oingo.com/apps/domainpark/domainpark.cgi?client=netw8744&s=www.doctorswithoutborders.org

Thats just evil ...

Posted by: at December 29, 2004 02:52 PM

I don't know if they are rated, but the UCC's International Relief Fund comes through a Christian Church with a history of caring about social justic issues and you can give your donation in another person's memory or honor. They'll even send a letter of acknowledgement to them. http://www.ucc.org/index2.html

Posted by: Lisa at December 29, 2004 03:22 PM

lc, those are good points. Big organizations may be slow and inefficient. However, they may also have certain economies of scale -- administrative salaries and the like may actually be a smaller percentage of a big charity's total funds, if the same number of people are moving more money. It pays to examine the details.

Anonymous, when I go to http://www.doctorswithoutborders.org , I get redirected to this page, which says "Doctors Without Borders web site is experiencing very heavy traffic". Anyone know why anonymous's results differ?

Frank, I've added information on the Salvation Army. They don't report information to Charity Navigator, because they are a church. But they are reported to be very efficient; you'll have to consult the links and see whether you find the sources credible.

Lisa, thanks for posting; I can't find any watchdog or rating information on UCC.


Posted by: Benjamin Rosenbaum at December 29, 2004 04:05 PM

lc - while it's true that smaller organisations might move faster in some situations, I personally give regularly to organisations like MSF *because* they're larger. The stocks of disaster supplies they have means that they're able to move very quickly to provide the resources that are needed - MSF is already moving the supplies in to establish a field hospital for thousands of people for a 3 month period. Personally I don't mind donating money that could be spent on the restocking of these supplies, because I know it's going to help continue the work that's already been started.

Posted by: Madeline at December 29, 2004 05:55 PM

Hmmm - I just tried donating to the American Red Cross via the Amazon Honor System page, but my contribution was denied because apparently there's a $50 limit. Also, the page describing the Honor System says Amazon takes 2.9% + $0.30 of each transaction. Anyone know if that limit or that Amazon fee is being changed for use by the ARC?

Posted by: Phil at December 29, 2004 06:33 PM

Please get the word out to people looking at ways of making a difference by helping those effected. On-line donations may be made at: http://www.giveworld.org/tsunami.htm.

Posted by: GiveWorld at December 29, 2004 08:14 PM

Thanks for posting this!

For thos who want to help out... I have added some Christian mission relief links to: www.heartformissions.net

Posted by: Heart for Missions at December 29, 2004 11:20 PM

Consider adding Christian Children's Fund. They have projects onsite throughout Indonesia, Sri Lanka, and India, and have already mobilized emergency plans in response to the tsunami, hoping to reach 50000 children in Indonesia alone. They are widely recognized as experts in dealing with trauma faced by children in areas ravaged by national disasters and ongoing war. They received an A rating from the Am. Institute of Philanthropy, and spend over 80% of their funds directly on program services to children (and despite the name, serve children of every race and creed).

Posted by: Christe McMenomy at December 30, 2004 01:31 AM

Phil, my impression is that Amazon is waiving that fee: "One hundred percent of your donation will go to the American Red Cross".

Heart For Missions, thanks for the additional links.

Christie, thanks, I have added CCF.

Re: GiveWorld, there is no watchdog information available from Charity Navigator, AIP or BB. However, their parent organization's 2003 Form 990 is online, which is an admirable degree of transparency. In 2003, GiveWorld started with $6,298.00 in assets, received $126,129.00 in revenues ($100K from one company), disbursed $4,445.00 in programs and spent $951.00 on management.

The good news: high transparency, lean administration, and a volunteer staff. The bad news: not much of a track record yet, perhaps?

However, looking deeper, I'm not sure if those numbers account for all donations made through GiveWorld to their partner NGOs? Basically, the model seems to be that GiveWorld screens grassroots NGOs in India, publishes a profile on each, breaks down what each donation will do, and requires the recipient NGOs to provide social-worker-case-report-like feedback on the results.

So it seems like it's potentially a lean, innovative model with an emphasis on transparency and accountability. It's not clear how much GiveWorld has in the way of resources for oversight of the recipient NGOs.

It's not clear how old GiveWorld is. Is this a start-up?

Posted by: Benjamin Rosenbaum at December 30, 2004 11:00 AM

I'd like to suggest Americares be added to the list:

Charity Navigator rates them highly. They spend an astonishing 99.0% of their income on the people they're trying to help, and their CEO doesn't pull down $600K+ a year in salary like the CEO of the American Red Cross. They also have an online form that earmarks donations for South Asian Earthquake Relief

Thanks,

- Mike

Posted by: at December 30, 2004 01:16 PM

Thanks Mike, added Americares.

I just donated to Asha for Education -- I'm impressed with their transparency, their efficiency, the flurry of on-the-ground activity on their blog, their size (small enough to seem to me to be nimble, large enough to be stable as an enterprise), their usually long-term focus (and the speed at which they adapted to respond to this disaster), and their structure -- they seem to be principally composed of Indians, in America and Europe as well as in India, organized into small chapters which make donations directly to grassroots NGOs.

The fact that, in this case, many of the donors living in the first world share a language and culture with recipients in Third World poverty, strikes me as a very good example of leverage -- look at their internship FAQ for an example of what I mean -- they take it for granted that interns will speak an Indian language and have a local friend or family member to stay with -- so it sounds like we're talking about a constant flow of donor Indians from the US and Europe dropping in on the recipient grassroots NGOs to help out while on summer break, family vacations, etc -- a wonderfully low-cost and reliable mechanism for oversight, it seems to me.

They also seem to be entirely volunteer-run -- according to their income statement, in 2003 they spent only $21K on general and administrative expenses, of which they account for about $14K explicitly in categories like banking fees, postage and printing, and advertising. I like the idea that none of my donation is going towards salaries or office rental, and that the money is nonetheless going straight to on-the-ground NGOs without any intermediaries. The only people getting paid here are Indian social workers and the like, and my dollar goes a lot farher in Indian social worker salaries than it would in paying American charity CEOs, etc.

I may make a donation to one of the larger charities as well, however. The one drawback of Asha is that India, while hard hit, seems to have relatively more resources to deal with the problems than places like Indonesia, which is devastated, and Myanmar, which is not letting anyone even know that there is a problem. So I'm interested in what are the most effective ways to reach those places.

Thanks to everyone for posting with your suggestions.

Posted by: Benjamin Rosenbaum at December 30, 2004 05:05 PM

Humanitarian Aid from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints is distributed at 100%. See contribution guidelines at www.lds.org

The church is already well established in most of the hard hit areas, and is already distributing from their storehouses.

Their assistance is non-demoninational.

Posted by: cllattun at December 31, 2004 04:48 AM

You're doing a fantastic job in providing information about making financial donations. Have you been able to find any information on how to offer assistance in caring for the orphaned children? e.g. fostering them?

Posted by: John at December 31, 2004 08:08 AM

The Lancet, perhaps the world's most presigious medical journal, published a very negative editorial about the Director of UNICEF recently:

http://pdf.thelancet.com/pdfdownload?uid=llan.364.9451.analysis_and_interpretation.31463.1&x=x.pdf

"It is widely, if regrettably, accepted that UNICEF has lost its way during Carol Bellamy’s long term of office."

Posted by: John Daly at December 31, 2004 11:44 AM

PayPal is now taking direct donatations for Unicef and waiving all their fees (I hope amazon waives their fees too). http://donations.paypal.com/

Did you hear that Bill Gates gave $3million out of his own foundation (not microsoft's money but his own) very nice move.

Posted by: -lc- at December 31, 2004 12:30 PM

We've set up a website that makes it even easier for people to generate funds for the tsunami relief effort. Please check out http://www.ReliefSearch.org.

Very simply, when users click on search results generated from ReliefSearch.org, the site earns revenues on a pay-per-click basis. All click revenues generated from these searches will help fund the victims of the Earthquake/Tsunami disaster. People can continue performing searches on the web as they normally would, only proceeds from their activities on ReliefSearch.org will help the cause. So, we're encouraging users to use the ReliefSearch.org search engine instead of Google or Yahoo!

Our goal is 1 million searches in the next 30 days. Anything you can do to help spread the word about ReliefSearch.org will be greatly appreciated.

Thanks so much for your help!

Posted by: Ben Padnos at January 2, 2005 10:00 AM

The United States Fund for UNICEF "funnels" money to UNICEF becuase that is its mission. UNICEF does not receive money from the UN, so there are 38 national committees that raise money and awareness about its causes. You can research their efficiency by looking at their annual reports on their websites: unicef.org and unicefusa.org.
Carol Bellamy has come under fire for her work at unicef, mostly from those who oppose her interest in increasing the opportunites for girls because they see this as some kind of hidden "women's rights" agenda.

Posted by: mayes at January 3, 2005 01:29 PM

I know some people who are involved with Asha, and can vouch that they are very committed. However, they are limited to India. You should consider Islamic Relief Worldwide, www.irw.org, who currently has relief operations running (from before the disaster) in Sri Lanka and in Indonesia. They are rated 4 stars by charitynavigator (http://www.charitynavigator.org/index.cfm/bay/search.summary/orgid/4438.htm), and over 90% of their funds go directly to programs to feed, clothe, and rehabilitate the poor.

Posted by: sifta at January 3, 2005 02:36 PM

Thanks for the information, clattun, John, John, lc, and mayes.

John, I don't know much about fostering orphans. There is reason to be cautious; the State Department has blocked adoptions: "the international standard in a crisis is to keep children as close to their family members as possible. It can be extremely difficult to determine whether children whose parents are missing are truly orphans."

UNICEF also advises caution: "In conflict and other emergency situations, UNICEF operates on the principle that no child should be adopted abroad unless it is firmly established that he or she has no parents, relatives or community members willing and able to care for the child."

Many affected areas lost disproportionately more children than adults -- there may be more parents who lost children in the tsunami, than children who lost parents. If local relatives can be provided with the resources to take care of the children, or local families can adopt them, those children may be much better off where they have a shared language, culture, religion, family, and where everyone around them has been through the same tragedy.

mayes, I did not mean to criticize United States Fund for UNICEF for channeling money to UNICEF -- obviously, that's their job. I wanted only to point out that comparing the expenses of different charities is not necessarily apples to apples: the Form 990 filed in the USA may not account for all the administrative expenses.

The UNICEF FAQ, however, does say the following: "When you make a donation to UNICEF, either on our website or by telephone (see above), you can choose to earmark your contribution for the tsunami relief effort or any other program. As each of UNICEF’s Country Offices have their own annual budget to cover their overhead costs, your donation can go solely to the relief effort."

Do you have any links to articles defending Carol Bellamy's administration of UNICEF? I'd love to offer any detailed opposing view.

Posted by: Benjamin Rosenbaum at January 3, 2005 03:40 PM

sifta, I have added IRW. Also added Sarvodaya, noted via the Science Fiction Writers of America newsletter.

Posted by: Benjamin Rosenbaum at January 3, 2005 04:56 PM

Stop by www.gfa.org/tsunami. This Christian organization keeps their administrative costs separate from designated donations. So 100% of your gift goes to the disaster relief. GFA was the first group on the site.

Check out this article by Christian Examiner.
http://www.christianexaminer.com/Articles/Articles%20Jan05/Art_Jan05_10.html

There is eternity.
ThinkOnIt

Posted by: DG at January 4, 2005 11:32 AM

You forgot Catholic Relief Services, which on December 30 announced a commitment of $25 million for emergency relief and long-term rehabilitation programs to assist people affected by the Dec. 26 tsunami. The amount represents one of the earliest and largest such commitments to date for the tsunami relief efforts. See www.catholicrelief.org

Posted by: at January 4, 2005 12:31 PM

Added Catholic Relief Services, and a comment urging people to consider giving beyond just funds earmarked for the tsunami.

Since I mentioned giving to Asha, I should add that I also gave to Sarvodaya, for somewhat similar reasons: grassroots organization, local employees, involved in more than just disaster relief. I don't have much data on its efficiency, but in this case I'm swayed by my regard for Arthur C. Clarke -- surely this can be forgiven of a science fiction writer! :-)

Posted by: Benjamin Rosenbaum at January 13, 2005 09:41 AM

Regards.
well I thakkar Dniesh am a socialworker willing to work with the NGOwhich is working for the Tsunami Victims in south india and so leaving this message for those who can help me contact those NGOs willing to employ my kinda socialworkers who really want to work for the society.
I have worked in local NGO for a year and now i would like to head for fresh challenges in order to utilize my potentials for the benefit of society and myself too.
Looking forward to hearing from you soon.
Thanking you in anticipation.
God Be with you and Tsunami Victims.

Posted by: Thakkar Dinesh at February 6, 2005 01:06 AM

Great job, Mr Rosenbaum. It's a bit late in the day to say this, i know, but we were kinda snowed under at with the response to our blogs.

peter

(Found you via Blogpulse's study on the Tsunami, in case you were wondering.)

Posted by: Peter Griffin at March 2, 2005 03:48 PM

the new balance Yellow michaelkors.com River nike so michael kors handbags tired? nfl steelers jerseys What michael kors is wholesale handbags the shoes outlet point? atl jerseys "I wavering nfl eagles jerseys with michael kors outlet store my nike factory hands coach outlet and hogan sito ufficiale feet, cheap ray ban pushing my tommy hilfiger outlet feet and christian louboutin thinking: mcm bags Today adidas.nl I vans would not michael kors go pandora charms home oakley store if celtics jerseys I could coach shop factory not go armani watches to easton bats China. thunder jerseys I ran cheap ray ban and valentino shoes ran nfl jerseys and mcm handbags finally montblanc ran home. roshe In nfl buccaneers jerseys the thomas sabo days vans shoes ahead, lebron james shoes there flat iron are still many barbour jackets outlet difficulties. ray ban I will swarovski online shop always inspire dsquared2 shoes me nike roshe run with nike air the spirit nfl bengals jerseys of chi flat iron the nike uk Long March. nfl vikings jerseys Long March bcbg max spiritual timberland shoes composition north face 900 word beats by dre headphones two eyeglasses frames "The air max Red reebok Army air max is not giuseppe zanotti afraid of nfl jerseys expedition difficult, nba jersey thousands versace clothes of ray ban uk miles only jordan retro 11 leisure." coach factory outlet Every time orlando magic jerseys I michael kors bags heard oakley outlet this the north face outlet heroic polo ralph lauren outlet online "Qilu miami heat jersey Long veneta March", oakley sunglasses outlet my vibram five fingers eyes mizuno wave will emerge rockets jerseys such skechers shoes outlet a nike roche scene: marc jacobs handbags Ludingqiao, nfl dolphins jerseys Dadu north face which clippers jerseys brave and brave sacramento kings jerseys figure; cheap eyeglasses snow-capped juicy couture handbags mountains, adidas mountains north face outlet and nfl azcardinals jerseys mountains that fred perry perseverance skechers canada and polo ralph lauren perseverance cheap oakley sunglasses footsteps; michael kors outlet online four Jones, nike shoes Chishui River michael kors after the nike jordan victory of nike shoes that nfl saints jerseys smile. kate spade handbags Seventy-six years nike roshe run ago, the tory burch ancestors hollister online shop used jimmy choo outlet their barbour mens jackets blood and ferragamo life polo ralph lauren to christian louboutin compose burberry outlet online the thomas sabo song true religion of the ralph lauren outlet online Long ralph lauren March, "shaking puma online shop heaven coach outlet online and ray-ban sunglasses earth." replica watches Today, golden state warriors we hermes belt are brooklyn nets reviewing iphone 5s cases the air max 2007 tragic and nike mercurial heroic history polo ralph lauren outlet of the oakley sunglasses unprecedented Long March. ralph lauren uk We are burberry outlet online not birkenstock taschen deutschland calling celine outlet on tommy hilfiger online everyone easton bats to tory burch sale measure the free running long nike air max journey nfl panthers jerseys again oakley with nike free his louboutin shoes footsteps. nike air max 90 Instead, moncler outlet we horloges must michael kors outlet online use longchamp our rolex watches inner feelings michael kors bags to michael kors outlet online sale realize ray ban that oakley standard issue facing ray bans the butcher's burberry outlet knives wholesale handbags and nike roshe run temptations, Daring nfl patriots jerseys spirit! To oakley sunglasses cheap inherit nfl jaguars jerseys and levis outlet carry hollister kids forward nfl titans jerseys the hollister bullets cheap jordans and north face canada fires in the forest and coach factory online grasslands, nfl 49ers jerseys play oakley sunglasses a rayban decadent true religion jeans outlet and hollister clothing unyielding prada handbags hard-bones lacoste outlet spirit burberry outlet online in order hogan to foster michael kors the timberland outlet spirit air max 90 of the cheap oakley sunglasses Long ed hardy March beats by dr dre of detroit pistons jersey the omega watches new era that ralph lauren polo we adidas zx study swarovski jewelry diligently beats headphones for bottega the jordans sake new balance shoes of oakley outlet online rejuvenating China. Firm conviction nhl jerseys and mlb jerseys win-win air jordan shoes confidence dre headphones are utah jazz jerseys the michael kors spiritual impetus ray ban outlet to overcome cheap true religion hardship. On the north face the way to rolex watches the vans Long swarovski March, birkenstock deutschland the fendi shoes forefathers reebok outlet marched mavericks jerseys on the air max pas cher solid coach bags outlet land of new balance Huaxia at oakley sunglasses cheap the north face jackets feet timberland boots of baseball jerseys their ancestors oakley vault and ray ban pas cher held high designer handbags the red bottom shoes banner nfl texans jerseys of juicy couture clothings rejuvenating longchamp handbags the nation in their thomas sabo outlet hands, swarovski crystal soaring hogan shoes their hearts adidas clothings and burberry outlet online dreams nba jerseys of flying prada outlet the hilfiger outlet motherland. timberland pas cher It true religion jeans women is such portland trail blazers jerseys a belief that they will asics be louboutin shoes closely coach factory outlet online together, instyler to build coach outlet store an air yeezy unbreakable, hugo boss unbreakable steel uhren shop wall. huarache It new york knicks jersey is burberry this nike air max belief salvatore ferragamo that supports them bcbg max azria through ray ban sunglasses the nhl jerseys difficult, ray ban outlet walked skechers mens shoes through air max 95 the huarache dangerous, nfl colts jerseys out supra shoes of hope, true religion jeans outlet out cheap oakley of louboutin a nfl chargers jerseys blue basketball shoes sky. nba jersey The air max revolutionary spirit ray-ban sunglasses of hard struggle oakley and supra shoes outlet sacrifice coach outlet usa is nfl bills jerseys the ray ban wayfarer fundamental fitflop shoes guarantee northface for mens hoodies victory. michael kors uhren In longchamp the philipp plein clothes face long champ of the michael kors outlet mighty enemy and the nuggets jersey sinister soccer shoes outlet natural environment phoenix suns jerseys during nfl chiefs jerseys the long prada sunglasses march, it salomon is nfl falcons jerseys precisely air max in pandora that ray ban prezzi spirit that doudoune north face the givenchy Red Army has milwaukee bucks jerseys conquered kate spade handbags the coach bags friday hardships swarovski canada and adidas shoes difficulties and memphis grizzlies jerseys overcame the nfl jets jerseys mighty kate spade bags enemy barbour outlet store and rolex replica won nike outlet the ultimate nike store victorious tn requin pas cher victory. It has thus ferragamo opened up indiana pacers jerseys a brand new ralph lauren uk road nfl broncos jerseys to nba jersey the Chinese mcm bags revolution woolrich clearance . ralph lauren Today, tommy hilfiger online shop as ralph lauren we christian louboutin outlet enter the nike free new century, we also nike id need swarovski crystal firm ray ban pas cher conviction. We omega watches also need michael kors outlet a hermes tracksuits strong barbour will. We huaraches also need washington wizards jerseys the ralph lauren factory store spirit of polo ralph hard work. kate spade outlet We mcm backpack outlet also ecco mens shoes need birkenstock the giuseppe zanotti sneakers spirit nike free trainer 5.0 of coach outlet dedication. tommy hilfiger canada With oakley pas cher such adidas online shop conviction and omega spirit, ray ban sunglasses outlet we michael kors purses can dansko shoes outlet defy nfl packers jerseys the hermes birkin difficulties calmly, face mcm backpack the calvin klein outlet difficulties with tenacity, overcome michael kors outlet the montre femme difficulties with tommy hilfiger outlet stores optimism, air jordan retro and nfl rams jerseys with ralph lauren outlet such hollister co conviction and boutique clothing spirit, we nike soccer shoes can nfl browns jerseys stimulate stone island jackets the air max thea creative ralph lauren outlet ability and hollister clothing store the iphone 4s cases passion to start a business with versace a hermes birkin bag vigorous under armour outlet and pandora jewelry upward coach black friday outlook , polo ralph lauren Glow invincible pandora jewellery australia power. adidas online shop This adidas belief, cle Jerseys the spirit coach factory outlet online is cheap coach purses the burberry sale cornerstone nfl bears jerseys of nfl lions jerseys our life converse to longchamp glory. long champ As nfl ravens jerseys a jerseys from china new michael kors boy with a marc jacobs handbags glorious oakley ambition, have polo ralph lauren outlet you air force ever 76ers jerseys wondered what ferragamo shoes new nfl seahawks jerseys responsibilities purses and handbags we nike factory outlet have omega watches on mizuno our toronto raptors jerseys shoulders michael kors outlet online sale in pumas the new Long bulls jersey March? air max shoes We must burberry take new orleans pelicans jerseys the north face backpacks glorious spurs jerseys banner nfl redskins jerseys of the spirit longchamp outlet of jimmy choo the nike Long March mbt shoes and plein shoes adapt ourselves tommy hilfiger to the requirements new balance of coach factory outlet the soccer jerseys development coach factory of asics gel the oakley times. prada We converse must polo ralph forge nfl raiders jerseys ahead with michael kors handbags determination nike roshe run and dsquared2 sale strive rolex watch to nike outlet forge ahead c.c beanies outlet so ralph lauren outlet online that hollister co we burberry handbags can michael kors outlet online sale truly nike air max turn michael kors bags the patriotic oakley holbrook ambition into burberry outlet a burberry outlet online trip to michael kors outlet online serve true religion outlet the jordan retro country. Today, polo outlet online in order to prada shoes rejuvenate michael kors purses China, coach factory outlet online we ferragamo shoes outlet will burberry handbags work air jordan diligently and fidget spinner make contributions louboutin shoes to nfl giants jerseys our lakers jersey future cheap barbour jackets to nike running shoes create a brilliant mlb jerseys future burberry handbags for minnesota timberwolves jerseys our burberry handbags motherland. "The converse sneakers long fred perry polos road is coming, and ray ban I pandora bracelet will chrome hearts clothings search." Students, pandora charms for converse outlet the new balance store great coach factory outlet rejuvenation babyliss flat iron of nfl cowboys jerseys our nation, let's hornets jersey work michael kors handbags together.

nike

Posted by: ylq at December 29, 2017 08:15 AM

the Yellow River burberry handbags so tired? cheap ray ban What coach outlet is polo ralph the burberry point? 76ers jerseys "I wavering with my air max 95 hands longchamp handbags and feet, thomas sabo pushing my the north face feet and thinking: tommy hilfiger online Today ray ban pas cher I juicy couture clothings would pandora bracelet not go nfl chiefs jerseys home if I could michael kors purses not go nike roshe run to michael kors outlet online China. nfl azcardinals jerseys I bcbg max ran kate spade outlet and ran adidas.nl and marc jacobs handbags finally barbour mens jackets ran home. nike outlet In designer handbags the air max thea days ahead, nfl panthers jerseys there ralph lauren factory store are swarovski online shop still lebron james shoes many difficulties. I nfl redskins jerseys will easton bats always inspire nike running shoes me mbt shoes with the dsquared2 shoes spirit of new balance the coach outlet store Long March. asics gel Long plein shoes March spiritual nfl colts jerseys composition supra shoes 900 givenchy word mcm bags two "The barbour Red Army bulls jersey is ralph lauren not rockets jerseys afraid tommy hilfiger canada of longchamp expedition nike difficult, air max thousands celtics jerseys of oakley miles montblanc only oakley vault leisure." roshe Every hollister co time I flat iron heard this nfl 49ers jerseys heroic nike mercurial "Qilu kate spade handbags Long michael kors outlet online sale March", nike roshe run my thomas sabo eyes will emerge cheap barbour jackets such nfl dolphins jerseys a nba jersey scene: Ludingqiao, nfl falcons jerseys Dadu barbour jackets outlet which uhren shop brave doudoune north face and woolrich clearance brave figure; snow-capped mountains, mountains skechers shoes outlet and toronto raptors jerseys mountains that michael kors outlet online sale perseverance burberry outlet online and nfl eagles jerseys perseverance hollister online shop footsteps; versace clothes four Jones, burberry outlet online Chishui huarache River hugo boss after veneta the nba jerseys victory ray ban pas cher of that smile. Seventy-six nfl jaguars jerseys years nhl jerseys ago, the hollister co ancestors long champ used swarovski crystal their new balance store blood marc jacobs handbags and north face life to ralph lauren compose cheap true religion the vibram five fingers song michael kors outlet of michael kors the Long louboutin shoes March, "shaking nfl packers jerseys heaven supra shoes outlet and nike soccer shoes earth." memphis grizzlies jerseys Today, hermes tracksuits we mlb jerseys are nike reviewing air jordan the montre femme tragic coach factory outlet online and boutique clothing heroic hermes birkin bag history of air max pas cher the burberry outlet unprecedented hornets jersey Long ecco mens shoes March. We puma online shop are prada outlet not polo outlet online calling new york knicks jersey on everyone nike uk to versace measure nike outlet the timberland outlet long nike factory outlet journey michael kors bags again with prada shoes his hermes belt footsteps. Instead, swarovski canada we mens hoodies must adidas zx use indiana pacers jerseys our inner milwaukee bucks jerseys feelings to coach bags friday realize christian louboutin that rolex watches facing air force the mcm backpack outlet butcher's nike roche knives ray ban and temptations, ray ban outlet Daring spirit! beats headphones To nike shoes inherit prada handbags and spurs jerseys carry forward hilfiger outlet the reebok outlet bullets north face and nfl titans jerseys fires in the chrome hearts clothings forest and grasslands, play cle Jerseys a bcbg max azria decadent nfl lions jerseys and north face backpacks unyielding true religion jeans outlet hard-bones cheap eyeglasses spirit ralph lauren outlet in michael kors outlet online order air max shoes to prada sunglasses foster sacramento kings jerseys the spirit valentino shoes of the north face outlet Long chi flat iron March converse outlet of easton bats the soccer shoes outlet new michael kors bags era that kate spade bags we rayban study nfl jets jerseys diligently nike for the cheap jordans sake omega watches of thomas sabo outlet rejuvenating China. polo ralph lauren Firm cheap oakley sunglasses conviction and celine outlet win-win ray bans confidence polo ralph lauren outlet are mcm bags the spiritual impetus nuggets jersey to oakley outlet online overcome ed hardy hardship. burberry handbags On hollister the nfl vikings jerseys way skechers canada to the louboutin shoes Long dsquared2 sale March, hogan sito ufficiale the nike jordan forefathers marched louboutin shoes on true religion the pandora jewelry solid michael kors outlet online sale land michael kors handbags of nfl raiders jerseys Huaxia timberland pas cher at the philipp plein clothes feet reebok of michael kors outlet store their ancestors calvin klein outlet and moncler outlet held nfl patriots jerseys high washington wizards jerseys the prada banner michael kors of mcm backpack rejuvenating soccer jerseys the ferragamo shoes outlet nation mizuno in nike free their hands, soaring tommy hilfiger their nhl jerseys hearts nba jersey and fitflop shoes dreams of ray ban prezzi flying asics the burberry outlet motherland. c.c beanies outlet It clippers jerseys is air max 2007 such a red bottom shoes belief iphone 5s cases that baseball jerseys they replica watches will omega watches be closely nfl bears jerseys together, giuseppe zanotti to ray ban outlet build nfl cowboys jerseys an unbreakable, coach factory outlet unbreakable cheap oakley sunglasses steel coach factory online wall. It adidas online shop is this belief michael kors handbags that minnesota timberwolves jerseys supports lakers jersey them beats by dre headphones through detroit pistons jersey the difficult, under armour outlet walked through instyler the ray ban sunglasses dangerous, mcm handbags out air max 90 of horloges hope, nfl bengals jerseys out of burberry a blue polo ralph lauren outlet online sky. The revolutionary air max spirit nike roshe run of hard ray ban struggle nfl broncos jerseys and sacrifice portland trail blazers jerseys is ray ban sunglasses outlet the levis outlet fundamental nike roshe run guarantee timberland shoes for victory. oakley In tory burch the michael kors face of bottega the fred perry polos mighty salomon enemy oakley sunglasses and pandora charms the burberry outlet online sinister nfl browns jerseys natural pandora environment omega watches during adidas clothings the long michael kors march, rolex replica it polo ralph lauren outlet is precisely mlb jerseys in michael kors handbags that spirit that the rolex watches Red nba jersey Army hollister clothing store has conquered adidas online shop the adidas hardships oakley sunglasses and vans difficulties coach outlet and overcame coach bags outlet the mighty enemy coach factory outlet online and juicy couture handbags won the christian louboutin ultimate victorious ralph lauren uk victory. louboutin It brooklyn nets has ferragamo thus nfl chargers jerseys opened hollister clothing up northface a michael kors brand oakley sunglasses outlet new road ferragamo shoes to new balance shoes the Chinese revolution . michaelkors.com Today, oakley store as we true religion jeans women enter ray-ban sunglasses the pandora charms new jimmy choo outlet century, we ray-ban sunglasses also nfl buccaneers jerseys need firm fred perry conviction. ray ban wayfarer We pandora jewellery australia also need a longchamp strong polo ralph lauren will. jordans We also need jordan retro 11 the spirit air max of skechers mens shoes hard polo ralph work. fidget spinner We north face canada also air jordan shoes need barbour outlet store the burberry outlet online spirit salvatore ferragamo of nike free dedication. ray ban uk With huarache such beats by dr dre conviction and thunder jerseys spirit, we swarovski jewelry can defy nike factory the new orleans pelicans jerseys difficulties calmly, face the difficulties mizuno wave with cheap oakley tenacity, hogan shoes overcome the oakley pas cher difficulties ralph lauren with new balance optimism, phoenix suns jerseys and with oakley outlet such miami heat jersey conviction hermes birkin and oakley spirit, pumas we michael kors outlet can stimulate tommy hilfiger online shop the kate spade handbags creative oakley sunglasses cheap ability and longchamp outlet the nfl jerseys passion michael kors to swarovski start tommy hilfiger outlet stores a business burberry sale with eyeglasses frames a babyliss flat iron vigorous dansko shoes outlet and atl jerseys upward vans outlook coach factory outlet , golden state warriors Glow armani watches invincible coach factory outlet power. nike air max This belief, nike air the swarovski crystal spirit nfl seahawks jerseys is oakley the mavericks jerseys cornerstone converse of new balance our adidas life nfl giants jerseys to nike air max 90 glory. As polo ralph lauren a nfl jerseys new boy nike shoes with burberry outlet online a coach outlet usa glorious stone island jackets ambition, have huaraches you ever hollister kids wondered burberry handbags what air jordan retro new air max responsibilities we have utah jazz jerseys on our longchamp shoulders hogan in coach black friday the michael kors outlet online new birkenstock deutschland Long orlando magic jerseys March? purses and handbags We jerseys from china must take christian louboutin outlet the nike air max glorious banner cheap ray ban of timberland boots the coach factory spirit of cheap coach purses the birkenstock taschen deutschland Long nfl saints jerseys March and ralph lauren uk adapt nfl steelers jerseys ourselves giuseppe zanotti sneakers to michael kors purses the requirements of nfl bills jerseys the nike air max development lacoste outlet of the jordan retro times. jimmy choo We must vans shoes forge ahead oakley standard issue with determination and strive to shoes outlet forge birkenstock ahead so converse that ralph lauren outlet we coach shop factory can wholesale handbags truly true religion jeans outlet turn the dre headphones patriotic ambition oakley sunglasses cheap into tn requin pas cher a ralph lauren outlet online trip to serve adidas shoes the free running country. ferragamo Today, iphone 4s cases in nike free trainer 5.0 order the north face outlet to rejuvenate China, nfl rams jerseys we wholesale handbags will air yeezy work diligently and basketball shoes make long champ contributions to tommy hilfiger outlet our coach factory outlet online future coach outlet online to oakley holbrook create nfl texans jerseys a converse sneakers brilliant future michael kors outlet for ralph lauren outlet online our true religion outlet motherland. fendi shoes "The long nfl ravens jerseys road rolex watch is coming, and I tory burch sale will ralph lauren polo search." michael kors uhren Students, for the great michael kors bags rejuvenation nike store of our north face jackets nation, omega let's nike id work burberry handbags together.

ray ban

Posted by: ylq at December 29, 2017 08:30 AM
Post a comment









Please choose one:


Thank you. Remember personal info?